OT: 7 July 1923 – H.S. Strafford [“Piobaireachd Playing at the Cowal Gathering”]

The Oban Times, 7 July, 1923 [Piobaireachd Playing at the Cowal Gathering] Rosegarth, Dunoon, 3 July, 1923 Sir,–Dr. Bannatyne’s views are, I believe, based upon a restricted knowledge of the activity presently prevailing amongst the piping fraternity. I have good reason to know there never was a time when the desire to excel in piping […]

Continue reading


OT: 7 July 1923 – Spaidsearachd Chlann Domhnuill “Piobaireachd Playing at the Cowal Gathering”

The Oban Times, 7 July, 1923 Piobaireachd Playing at the Cowal Gathering 2nd July 1923 Sir,–I am very much surprised that Dr. Bannatyne, of all men, should say that the fingers of a lad of 18 years and under are incapable of playing a piobaireachd with effect. Notwithstanding the Doctor’s undoubted knowledge of anatomy, I […]

Continue reading


OT: 7 July 1923 – Highland Officer “‘Flowers Of the Forest’ and ‘Lochaber No More'”

The Oban Times, 7 July, 1923 “Flowers Of the Forest” and “Lochaber No More” 1st July, 1923 Sir,–Your correspondent “Manu Forti” writing in your issue of June 23 last, points out an aspect of modern piping which certainly requires attention being drawn to it. With a great number of appropriate and suitable old Highland laments, […]

Continue reading


OT: 30 June 1923 – Enthusiast “‘Canntaireachd’ or the Vocable Method of Recording Piobaireachd”

The Oban Times, 30 June, 1923 “Canntaireachd” or the Vocable Method of Recording Piobaireachd Sir,–It would be interesting to know if any manuscript recording pibrochs by the MacCrimmon system, other than that taken down by Captain MacLeod of Gesto, exists. The Gesto record was published, and the reprint dated 1880 appears to contain many clerical […]

Continue reading